Incident Report
Combustible Gas Monitoring System in Furnace Room Found Inoperable
Incident Date: 1996
Severity:
Near-Miss
Was Hydrogen released?
Uncertain
Was there Ignition?
No
Description
During a facility walk-through, it was noted that a combustible gas (hydrogen) monitoring system installed in a furnace room was inoperable (the system had been unplugged). This system is used to detect and warn facility employees of an explosive or flammable environment. An explosive or flammable environment can only occur if there is a leak in the system, which would not be expected to occur during normal operations. When the system was reactivated, no leaks were indicated.
The incident had the following three causes:
- A procedure describing administrative controls necessary to ensure safe operations in the area should have been developed and implemented prior to disabling the hydrogen monitoring system.
- The hydrogen monitor was not hard-wired, which allowed it to be unplugged and rendered inoperable.
- The hydrogen monitors were disabled and the status of the monitors was not communicated to personnel that work in the area.
Setting
- Furnace Room
Equipment
Safety Systems
- Measurement/Sensing Device
Damage and Injuries
- None
Probable Cause(s)
- Design Flaw
- Lack of Protocol/SOP
Contributing Factors
- Communication
- Human Error
No Characteristics Defined.
The incident was discovered During Inspection.
Lessons Learned/Suggestions for Avoidance/Mitigation Steps Taken
Work preplanning is essential whenever maintenance or work activities may have an adverse impact on everyday operations. When there are changes to the operational status of any critical system, especially a safety critical system, those changes must be communicated to affected personnel. SOPs and OPs must be fully implemented and the implementation should be verified during facility and organizational assessments.
Date Added to H2Incidents: 6/26/2006

